About Eagan Insurance

Established in 1954, Eagan Insurance is one of the oldest and most respected independent insurance agencies in the Greater New Orleans area. Built on a foundation of integrity, stability, and strength, we have proudly served individuals and businesses for over 70 years. Under our motto, "Family to Family, Business to Business," we provide a full spectrum of insurance services, including:

• A robust Personal Lines Division

• A comprehensive Commercial Property & Casualty Department

• A rapidly growing Employee Benefits Division

Eagan Insurance takes pride in understanding the complex needs of its clients and navigating today's volatile insurance market with creative solutions, expert service, and competitive pricing.

In April 2024, Eagan Insurance joined forces with Higginbotham—the largest independent insurance, financial, and HR services firm headquartered in Texas, and one of the top firms in the nation. This partnership enhances our ability to serve clients while maintaining the personalized attention and local expertise that defines who we are.

Residential Insurance

1-4 Family Dwellings Less Than $1,000,000 in Value

Crystal Wallis

Personal Lines Account Manager, Middle Market Homes (Less than $1M)

cwallis@higginbotham.net | (504) 836-9640

Single Family Homes Greater Than $1,000,000

Amy Roth, CIC, CISR, CPIW

Personal Lines Account Executive, High Value Homes (More than $1M)

aroth@higginbotham.net | (504) 836-9632

Premises Liability for 1-4 Unit Residential Properties

Laura Calcagno

Associate - Rental Liability

lcalcagno@higginbotham.net | (504) 836-9684

Commercial Insurance

Commercial / Multifamily - Greater than 4 Units

Marcus Eagan, CIC, CRM

Sophia Grosch Robertson, CIC

Managing Director

meagan@higginbotham.net | (504) 836-9687

Commercial Lines Account Executive

srobertson@higginbotham.net | (504) 836-9651

These accounts will be written and serviced directly by Marcus Eagan and Sophia Robertson.

Marcus and Sophia will be the points of contact for all quoting and service items (lender requirements, certificates, etc.)

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel